Skip to content

Rules Always Fail

We live in a world that wants certainty, where there is a fear of uncertainty. Unfortunately one of he core tenants of physics is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Our human response to this, is putting in rules, and in that bureaucracies are born!

Sally entered the Everdawn building carrying a box which clearly came from a bakery, one used to carry cakes. The building was the showcase “Experience Center” for Everdawn, personal, elegant and efficient. Their vision…to make Healthcare about Health and Care.

Sally was here to visit her father, it was his birthday and he was in hospice. Sally walked up to the check-in counter solemnly, making eye contact with the young man in front of her.

“Hi Owen, my name is Sally, I’m here to see my father, he’s in room 618.” She knew his name, not by familiarity, but by the badge he wore on his chest and she always greeted people by their name.

Owen smiled at being called by name and responded with a simple, “let me get you checked-in.”

A few quick strokes on a hidden keyboard, his gaze focused on the monitor Sally couldn’t see. The interaction stretched out like a suspense scene in a movie. Owen watched the spinning icon, the flashing “loading…” 10 seconds became 20, 30, finally after 60 seconds he got his response.

PATIENT — POLICY VIOLATION

He blinked. “One moment,” he said, because “one moment” is what you say when you’re about to enter the labyrinth. He opened the policy tooltip.

Reason: Visiting Hours Violation Detected.
Action Required: Supervisor Override + Compliance Note + Ticket #

Sally shifted her weight, the cake heavy in her arms. “Is something wrong?”

Owen felt his throat tighten. The banner didn’t say hospice. It didn’t say birthday. It said: visiting hours violation. He looked up at her face, tired, hopeful, trying not to beg.

“No,” he said gently. “Nothing’s wrong. The system just… needs an extra step.”

“A step,” she repeated. Her smile thinned. “How long?”

Owen glanced toward the back office where a supervisor sat behind a wall of monitors filled with dashboards. He could already imagine the response: open a ticket, attach a note, wait for approval, document the exception, close the loop.

Every rule needed a detector.

Every detector needed enforcement.

Every enforcement step needed a team.

He turned back to the woman. “It shouldn’t be long,” he said, and hated himself for how often he had to say that.

Owen had helped build this place back when the company was small enough that everyone still knew everyone’s first name. Everdawn had started as a promise: a company built around Health and Care.

Not performative care, real care. The kind that shows up in small decisions: trusting frontline judgment, listening to customers like they are humans, fixing the flaw instead of enforcing a rule or punishing someone for the exception. In the early days, when Owen joined, the internal motto wasn’t printed on posters. It was a “culture”, the way we do things here, it was a process!

If a problem happened, you asked, What’s the right thing to do? Then you fixed the thing that needed fixing. If an exception happened, you didn’t build a bureaucracy around it. You learned from it. Their systems were simple, responsive, and human.

Then the company grew too fast. It grew into the kind of success that makes everything feel urgent: new markets, new services, new partners, new headlines. Growth brought complexity, complexity brought mistakes, mistakes brought fear. And fear, quietly, reliably, brought rules.

It started with something small: a billing error that went viral. A customer posted a video of receiving the wrong bill. It wasn’t harmless, it was simple human error. But the internet doesn’t trade in nuance, the story became the narrative and the narrative became the risk.

Leadership asked the question leaders always ask when they’re afraid:

“How do we make sure this never happens again?”

Someone said, “We need stricter controls.”

At that moment, a rule was born. The rule felt rational at first. It created the illusion of safety. If you specify everything, you won’t fail again. But living systems don’t work like that, it’s impossible to foresee everything. The moment you add a rule, you also add:

  • something that defines the rule
  • something to detect the violation
  • something to enforce compliance
  • an audit report for review

What gets missed is subtle, invisible, the human impact of the rule, conflicts with other rules, and the exceptions the rule will inevitably create.

The machine grows limbs. A second viral mistake happened, a customer’s procedure was held up because of a mis-scan. Leadership flinched again. Another rule, then another, eventually a whole new department called Risk Assurance with dashboards that measured “Policy Adherence” to monitor the rules. It became the heartbeat of the business. They trained frontline staff to follow scripts that sounded compassionate but were engineered to avoid liability. It was all defensible. It was all countable. It was also quietly killing the thing that made Everdawn beautiful: trust. Owen watched the change like you watch the countryside get paved over one “development” at a time.

In the Experience Center, Sally waited. Owen opened the ticketing system. New ticket. Category: Patient Services. Subcategory: Visiting Hours Violation. Required fields: twelve. He typed with the muscle memory of someone who had learned to perform compliance the way other people perform kindness. He attached a note.

Customer visit for birthday, patient in hospice. Needs release.

He clicked submit. A timer appeared: Estimated response: 45 minutes.

Owen felt anger rise, clean and bright. Forty-five minutes wasn’t time on a dashboard, it was a daughter holding a cake while her father’s clock was ticking towards zero.

He walked to the back office and knocked on the supervisor’s doorframe. Talia looked up. Her desk was a small fortress of screens: queue metrics, compliance alerts, escalation logs, exception trends. She used to be a great frontline worker like him, warm, fast, and human. Now she looked like someone whose job was to be the nervous system for a machine that had forgotten its body, and it was taking a toll on hers.

“Talia,” Owen said quietly. “I need an override.”

She didn’t sigh, but her eyes did. “Which policy?”

“Visiting Hours Violation”

Talia clicked through three windows. “Ticket?”

“It’s in the queue.”

“No ticket, no override,” she said automatically, then caught herself and softened. “You know I can’t. They audit overrides now.”

“They audit sanity?” Owen asked before he could stop himself.

Talia’s face tightened. “They audit everything.”

Owen lowered his voice. “It’s for a birthday for a patient in hospice.”

Talia paused. For a second, he saw the old Talia, the one who felt the weight of the situation and used to bend toward human reality as if it mattered more than procedure. Then the compliance alert on her screen pinged red. Talia’s shoulders tensed, the system tugged her back into position.

“I’m sorry,” she said. “If we override without the process, we get flagged.”

Flagged. Another word that turns a person into a threat. Owen looked at her. “What are we protecting?” he asked, quietly.

Talia’s jaw struggled. “The company.”

Owen nodded. “And what else?”

Talia didn’t answer. Because that was the problem. They could still say “customer trust” in presentations. But the system was no longer oriented around it. The system was oriented around avoiding blame. Owen returned to the counter.

Sally’s arms trembled slightly. “I’m so sorry,” Owen said. “It’s going to be a bit longer than it should.” Her eyes were wet but steady. “The rest of the family is coming, dad might not be awake when they get here” she said softly, not accusing, just stating reality.

Something inside Owen snapped into place, not outwardly, not dramatically. Just a decision, like healing a broken bone. He imagined the original intent of Everdawn, what it had been built to do: serve life, not scripts. Help people, not protect dashboards.

He looked at the HOLD banner again. He could follow the process, keep his job safe, and keep his record clean. Or he could do what the system was supposed to do in the first place: meet the need in front of him. Owen reached under the counter and pulled out a simple release form, an old internal tool from the pre-rule era, meant for urgent situations. It had been unofficially retired, but the paper still lived in the drawer like a memory. He filled it out quickly. He didn’t feel heroic. He felt afraid. But it was a clean fear, the fear that comes when you choose integrity over protection. He reached under the counter, pressed a buzzer and the entrance gate lock clicked open. “Go ahead,” he said gently.

Her face broke open in relief and shock. “Thank you,” she whispered, and then she was gone, moving fast, the cake cradled in her arms. Owen watched her leave and felt the weight of what he’d done settle into his body. He had broken a rule. He had also kept a promise the company no longer remembered it made.

The Reckoning

It came several days later, a compliance notification hit his inbox:

Unauthorized Release Detected
Meeting Scheduled — 2:00 PM

Owen sat in the conference room across from two people he barely knew: a Risk Assurance manager in a crisp shirt and a Compliance Analyst with a laptop open like a weapon. Talia sat beside Owen, pale, hands folded across her chest.

The manager spoke in the calm tone of institutional righteousness. “We’re here to understand why you bypassed a protocol.”

Owen felt his heart thud. He could feel the old survival impulse: profess ignorance, avoid blame, say the right words. Instead, he told the truth. He described the daughter, her father, hospice, and the clock. The human reality the process couldn’t sense, the analyst typed, expression flat.

The manager nodded slowly. “We sympathize,” he said, and Owen felt the word sympathize used like a bandage to cover a wound that needed stitches. “But protocol exists to prevent downstream risk.”

Owen breathed in, steadying himself. “What risk?” he asked.

The manager’s mouth tightened. “Fraud. Mistakes. Precedent.”

Owen nodded. “Those are real risks. But do you know what else is a real risk?”

Silence. Owen continued, voice calm. “A system that doesn’t respond to life. A system that trains people to ignore what’s in front of them because the dashboard can’t count it.”

The manager shifted, annoyed. Owen didn’t raise his voice. He didn’t preach. He simply held the question in the room like a mirror. “What are we protecting?” he asked. “And what are we sacrificing to protect it?”

Talia’s breath hitched. The analyst’s fingers slowed. The manager stared at Owen as if Owen had broken not just a rule, but attacked his reality. In the corner of the room, a poster read: CUSTOMER CARE. Owen looked at it and felt something like grief. They’d turned care into procedure, love into a script.

Then Talia spoke, quiet, unexpectedly. “We’ve been writing rules to cover fear,” she said. Her voice shook slightly. “And every rule creates another exception. The queue keeps growing. People keep waiting. We’re  losing the original point.”

The manager’s face hardened. “This isn’t philosophical.”

Owen nodded. “It’s operational,” he said. “and it’s not humane.”

He proposed something simple, concrete: Stop responding to exceptions with permanent rules. Create a short, trusted “human judgment lane” for urgent cases, timeboxed, logged, reviewed daily. Measure what matters: time-to-resolution, customer recovery, frontline trust, real outcomes. Use a process to repair mistakes quickly instead of building new cages for everyone.

The manager frowned, but he didn’t dismiss it outright. Maybe because the queue was exploding. Maybe because customer satisfaction had quietly started slipping. Maybe because the machine was showing symptoms they could no longer ignore.

The analyst finally looked up. “If we did that,” she said cautiously, “we’d need a feedback loop.” Owen almost smiled. Yes, that’s the missing piece.

Less rules.

More feedback.

Continuous learning.

Rapid repair.

A living process that could breathe.

Aftermath

A month later, the Experience Center still looked polished. but something underneath had changed. There was a new practice, not a poster, not a slogan. A daily fifteen-minute review where urgent overrides were discussed openly: what happened, what was learned, how to fix flaws without punishing humanity.

Frontline staff were trusted again, not infinitely, not recklessly, with boundaries, with principles, a clear return path when reality drifted. The queue shrank. People stopped hiding behind scripts. Small truths returned to the room. And Owen, still imperfect, still human, felt the strange relief of a system remembering its purpose. Talia even felt different, no longer in the role of enforcer she could actually collaborate on solutions.

He thought often of the daughter with the cake. Not because he wanted credit, but because she was the original intent, she was what the system was built to serve. Rules hadn’t been evil. They were the expression of fear, trying to keep the company safe. But fear, left unexamined, always grows, more detection, more enforcement, more bureaucracy. It multiplies until the system becomes bloated, spending more time monitoring than actually producing because it can no longer sense what is real.

That’s when rules fail, not because rules are always wrong. But because rules can’t replace values, human judgment, and a living process. A living system stays alive by sensing, adapting, creating and repairing, by measuring what matters and acting at the speed of reality.

On a rainy evening, Owen walked across the pedestrian bridge outside the headquarters, the one Everdawn had funded years ago. Its lights pulsed softly, feeling the steel under his feet, beautiful in the clean, engineered way beauty can be. He stopped at the center and looked down at the river moving darkly beneath.

A bridge can be perfect and still fail its purpose if it doesn’t connect the people who need to cross. A system can be perfectly compliant and still abandon the human in front of it. Owen breathed in the cold air and felt, for the first time in a long time, something like hope, without performance. Not the hope of tighter control, the hope of wiser design, because the truth was simple and sharp:

Rules always fail a living system.

When rules replace the reasons the system exists, the only way back is not more rules. It’s values you can feel, principles you can hold, and processes that bring you home when you drift.